From Intuition to Mechanism
The statement “Coaching works” isn’t enough. The real question is: How does it work? The answer to this question clarifies both the limits of coaching and how it can best be used.
Anthony Grant is one of the first academics at the University of Sydney to systematically research the psychology of coaching. The International Coaching Federation’s (ICF) 2020 meta-analysis covers more than 50 studies. The findings show that coaching has significant effects on goal achievement, self-efficacy, psychological well-being, and job performance.
These effects occur through five mechanisms.
Mechanism 1: Self-Awareness
The questions asked during a coaching session are ones that don’t typically arise spontaneously in daily life. “What’s really behind this decision?” “Where does this pattern begin?” “Is this really what I want?”
Tasha Eurich’s research on self-awareness shows that people’s capacity to view themselves objectively is much lower than they think (Insight, 2017). Coaching systematically enhances this capacity. This is because a question posed from the outside reveals something different than a question generated from within.
Mechanism 2: Accountability
The statement “You’ll do this by next week” seems simple. But research shows that an accountability framework significantly increases commitment tracking.
Gail Matthews’ study at California Dominican University (2015) found that those who wrote down their goals and shared weekly progress reports achieved a 33 percent higher success rate compared to those who merely thought about their goals. Coaching reestablishes this structure in every session.
Mechanism 3: Broadening Perspective
When you look at the same problem for too long, your field of vision narrows. Frames like “I can’t do this,” “there’s no other option,” and “it’s always been this way” start to feel like reality.
Instead of directly suggesting solutions, the coach uses questions to open the door to alternative perspectives. Daniel Kahneman’s concept of the “outsider’s perspective” comes into play here: what would someone else see if they looked at this situation? This question helps you step outside your automatic thinking.
Mechanism 4: Alignment with Values
When decisions and actions don’t align with values, tension arises. Coaching sessions make this tension visible and create space for value-based action.
Steven Hayes’ ACT research shows that value alignment is directly related to motivation and psychological well-being (1999). Coaching structurally supports this alignment.
Mechanism 5: New Behavior Within a Safe Space
Change happens not by knowing, but by doing. But there’s usually a barrier before new behaviors can be tried: fear of failure, anxiety about being judged, or uncertainty about what will happen.
The coaching relationship reduces this barrier. Thinking about and trying new approaches in a non-judgmental, confidential, and supportive space becomes much easier in daily life.
“Coaching is the art of making visible what a person already knows but cannot see.” > Anthony Grant, University of Sydney’s Unit of Coaching Psychology
Cevvela’s Perspective
- Coaching operates not through intuition but through five psychological mechanisms: self-awareness, accountability, perspective broadening, value alignment, and new behaviors in a safe space.
- An ICF meta-analysis demonstrates the effects of coaching on goal achievement, self-efficacy, and job performance in accordance with research standards (2020).
- An accountability framework increases commitment tracking by thirty-three percent (Matthews, 2015).
- Coaching isn’t for everyone; it yields the best results for those who are goal-oriented, ready for change, and actively engaged.
- Understanding these mechanisms clarifies what to expect from coaching and demonstrates how the process can be utilized.
{{contact}} To discuss this topic with Cevvela {{/contact}}