Why It’s Important to Ask This Question
Working with the wrong type of support is, at best, a waste of time; in some cases, it’s a real risk. Seeking coaching when therapy is needed can make the problem worse. Conversely, turning to therapy when coaching would suffice is an unnecessary burden.
That’s why this question is legitimate and important.
The Fundamental Distinction: Past and Future
A common framework: “Therapy works with the past; coaching looks to the future.” This simplification serves as a starting point but isn’t entirely accurate.
A clearer distinction: Therapy addresses disorders, traumas, and patterns that hinder functioning. Coaching, on the other hand, supports someone who is already functioning well in achieving their goals, unlocking their potential, and growing.
The ICF’s ethical principles clearly state that coaches cannot make clinical diagnoses or treat psychological disorders.
When Is Therapy Necessary
The following situations indicate a need for therapy: clinical depression or anxiety disorders, trauma and PTSD, eating disorders, addiction, crisis situations, suicidal thoughts, or when past experiences significantly impair daily functioning.
In these cases, coaching is insufficient. A good coach recognizes this boundary and provides appropriate referrals.
When Is Coaching Appropriate
The following situations indicate a need for coaching: there is a clear goal but the path forward is uncertain; career or life transitions; feeling stuck when making a decision; identifying and developing strengths; recognizing and changing patterns—but only if these patterns do not clinically impair functioning.
The Gray Area
Some situations fall between these two extremes. For example, mild anxiety: a therapist can work with it, as can a mindful coach—provided it’s not a situation requiring clinical intervention.
The safest approach in this gray area is to have an evaluation session with a mental health professional and then make a decision.
Both at the Same Time
Coaching and therapy are not mutually exclusive. More often than not, they complement each other. While therapy works with past experiences, coaching can focus on the present and the future. However, someone working with both should ensure that their coach and therapist coordinate their efforts.
“A good coach knows their own limits. Attempting to answer a question that belongs to therapy through coaching serves neither the client nor the process.” > Adapted from the ICF Code of Ethics
Cevvela’s Perspective
- Therapy heals; coaching develops—the distinction is based on diagnosis and functionality.
- Therapy is necessary in cases of clinical depression, trauma, crisis, and disorders; coaching is insufficient in these situations.
- Coaching and therapy can be conducted simultaneously and often complement each other.
- A good coach knows their own limits and refers clients when necessary—this is an ethical requirement.
- In uncertain situations, an evaluation consultation with a mental health professional is the safest starting point.
{{contact}} To discuss this topic with Cevvela {{/contact}}