Why Mentoring Fails

The vast majority of failed mentoring relationships are doomed from the start. The parties involved are unaware of this. After a few meetings, the relationship quietly fizzles out, and everyone concludes that “mentoring doesn’t work.”

In reality, the problem isn’t with mentoring itself, but with how that specific relationship was established.

Poor Match

This is the most common reason—and the one least often recognized.

There may be a good alignment in titles or industries, but there might not be a values alignment. If that person’s understanding of career, definition of success, and communication style don’t align with yours, the relationship will be challenging no matter how knowledgeable they are.

A mismatch in values may be noticeable during the first meeting but is often overlooked. The expectation that “maybe we’ll get along better later” usually doesn’t pan out.

Unclear Expectations

Most people who enter a mentoring relationship saying, “I just want general support,” end up disappointed.

Unclear expectations make it unclear what the mentor should focus on. Each meeting goes in a different direction. No progress is made. Both parties begin to question the value of the relationship.

Before mentoring begins, this question must be answered: What do I want to achieve in this relationship in six months? If you can’t answer this question, you may not be ready for mentoring yet.

Lack of Structure

How often will you meet? How long will the meetings last? Who will set the agenda? When these questions remain unanswered, the relationship quickly becomes unclear.

If these matters aren’t discussed during the first meeting, appointments will start getting skipped within a few weeks. One person might say they’re “busy,” while the other hesitates to take the lead. Eventually, the relationship is effectively dead, though no one has officially called it off.

Structure isn’t trust. But it is the foundation of trust.

Imbalance of Power

Good mentoring isn’t a conversation, but it isn’t a monologue either.

If the mentor spends the entire session recounting their own experiences, you simply become a listener. This may be instructive, but it does not fulfill the function of mentoring. The relationship must be one where the mentor sees you, examines your specific situation, and provides feedback tailored to you.

Conversely, some mentors bounce every question back to you and offer no perspective of their own. This isn’t even coaching—it’s merely passive listening. Few mentors strike the right balance between sharing their experience and asking guiding questions.

The Responsibility to Maintain the Relationship

Maintaining the mentoring relationship is not generally perceived as the mentor’s responsibility. And that’s true. Keeping the mentoring relationship alive is largely the mentee’s responsibility.

Preparing an agenda, initiating meeting requests, taking notes between sessions, and tracking progress are the mentee’s responsibilities. Someone who fails to do this also causes the mentor to become passive.

What to Do When It Doesn’t Work Out?

Instead of quietly walking away, it’s better to openly end the relationship. A brief, honest feedback adds value to both you and your mentor. The statement, “This format isn’t working for me, so I’d like to end the relationship,” is perfectly sufficient.

Then ask yourself: What didn’t work in this relationship, and how can I do things differently next time?

Mentoring isn’t a product. It involves trial and error.

{{contact}} To build a successful mentoring relationship with Cevvela {{/contact}}